Monday, June 22, 2009

Post I Made in the LOSTpedia forums regarding Sawyer in S6

Recently, for whatever reasons, I started reading the LOSTpedia forums. I found that the idea that Sawyer would die in S6 because it was the only way for him to be "redeemed" to be prevalent. Thus, I started a thread countering this idea. You can see it here or read the text of my post here:

The possibility of Sawyer dying exists, but if it occurs, it will not be of his own will in a move of "heroic self sacrifice." If it occurs, it will be tragically at the hands of another person, similar to Rorschach in the movie Watchmen. It is my argument that if Sawyer were to sacrifice himself for "the greater good" it would contradict everything the writers have done with his character (and arguably the entire show).

Sawyer's journey is not one of "being a jerk" to "being a hero." That interpretation is both simplistic and uneducated. Rather, his journey is about realizing he has a moral sanction to live or, in other words, from self hatred to self love (and the moral responsibility that loving yourself carries).

To better understand this journey, we have to turn to the philosopher that wrote most in depth on this concept out of anyone in the history of mankind, Ayn Rand. A famous work of Rand's is "The Virtue of Selfishness," a book that unpacks the commonly accepted belief that altruism (living life for others) is the best morality to live by and challenges it by properly defining "selfishness" as the best morality to live by. The writers of LOST have extremely intentionally incorporated Randian philosophy into Sawyer's story (and arguably the story of the entire show). I could point to many examples, but there are five main points I feel prove my case. The first three refer to Sawyer specifically. The final two refer to the Season Five finale.

1. In Season 2, Sawyer was reading The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand while sitting on the beach. The novel follows its hero Howard Roark, who lives his life selfishly or for himself, and contrasts him with what Rand calls "secondhanders," people who live life secondhand or for other people. However, Sawyer has read many books. Are we then to assume he is getting his period for the first time like the titular Margaret in Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret.

No, what makes the appearance of The Fountainhead so important is that Damon Lindelof specifically mentioned it in the Season 3 DVD special feature "The LOST Book Club." In it, he said he thought Sawyer would identify greatly with Roark. It is since clear how much Sawyer did, and how much Randian thought has influenced him.

2. The Season 5 Dharmaville confrontation in Namaste between Sawyer and Jack was a Randian critique of his personality type and philosophy of "Live Together, Die Alone." Sawyer's key statement was as follows:

Quote:
I heard once Winston Churchill read a book every night, even during the blitz. He said it made him think better. That's how I like to run things. I think. I'm sure that doesn't mean that much to you because back when you were calling the shots, you pretty much just reacted.
This idea of thinking vs reacting is straight out of Randian, um, thought. For Rand, what makes humans humans, to put it very simply, is our ability to think. Every animal has some unique trait that differentiates it from other animals, our is our mind. Thus, to be human is to think, as you are doing the thing that is uniquely human. A key quote spoken by Roark in The Fountainhead explains this point better than I could:

Quote:
When you suspend your faculty of independent judgment, you suspend consciousness. To stop consciousness is to stop life.
But what does this idea of the importance of thinking have to do with Sawyer's arc and the idea of selfishness being a virtue? First, let's look at the latter half of that question. The statement "I think" begins with the word "I." Therefore, in order to think you must acknowledge yourself first. In other words, no one else can think for you. It is impossible to live as a secondhander. Now, consider the fact that Sawyer made that exact statement in his argument to Jack. This man who hated himself so much that he used his rhetorical skills to create a bad public image for himself made the ultimate statement of self love! (Does this mean Sawyer's arc is over? I don't believe so. The importance of love to his story and Randian philosophy will be unpacked in Season 6.)

But aren't I reading too much into this dialogue? Maybe the idea of self worth and thinking being tied up together with Sawyer and in Rand's philosophy is merely a coincidence? The following points will address that critique.

3. Upon Kate's return to the island in Season 5, the writers were sure to point out the real reason Sawyer jumped out of the helicopter in the Season 4 finale. Whereas the majority of the viewers believed it was a heroic action (because it was for other people), it was actually extremely cowardly out of self hatred. Why did Sawyer jump? Because, as he told Kate, he didn't believe he would be a good boyfriend to her or father to Clementine. In other words, what he wanted was to leave the island, but the fuel tank getting shot to give into his fears (or The Doubt as I like to call it). As bitter as Cassidy was in The Little Prince she was right about Sawyer's cowardice.

It is apparently obvious from this understanding of the helicopter scene, that Sawyer's journey is all about self worth, and that the writers were very much critiquing the heroic action of self sacrifice by pointing out that it is not actually done for other people at all (but that is an entire other discussion of the motivations of secondhanders).

"The Incident" continued these Randian themes through the corruption of Locke and the low self esteem demonstrated by many of the characters, most notably Ben and Jack.

4. Something Rand critiques greatly is religion, as she believes many people use it to live secondhand lives, allowing a more powerful being to provide them answers rather than their own thought. To be completely truthful, she is an atheist and believes the secondhanders live their lives based upon the "Mystics," those who claim to know about the mystic ways of the world. The manipulation of Locke by Eddie (or Essau or Anti-Jacob or whatever name you use) was only possible because Locke lived his life based upon "The Island." In other words, from the moment Locke arrived on the island, he was living a secondhand life, substituting his own will for the will of the island. It is apparently obvious this substitution occurred because of Locke's low self worth (he tried to substitute his will for his Dad's or Helen's off the island). We now know that for the entirety of the first five seasons, the island's will was really Eddie's, as he was manipulating Locke and Ben into being his loophole. This arc is a completely Randian critique of faith and religion. Notice how throughout the first five seasons, several characters acted as Mystics for Locke, most notably Ben and Richard (and, ironically, in Season Five we saw how Locke was a Mystic for Richard throughout the series).

Though LOST appears religious on its face, this Randian critique of mysticism runs through the series. I'm sure you can think of many examples, but I'd like to point out that, for awhile, a main character was a fake priest!

5. For my final point, I'd like to turn to my signature, and two characters in "The Incident": Ben and Jack. Both make the same error as Locke for the same reason: low self esteem.

I don't believe I need to cut and paste Ben's entire speech to Jacob here. We all know the content. However, the end is important. Ben's low self esteem prevents him from thinking about what he is about to do. Rather, he asks, "What about me?" Jacob responds, "What about you?" Sure, Jacob is egging Ben on so Ben will murder him, but he is also making a point. You’re focused on Jacob, Ben. What about the decision of whether to kill or not to kill? Ben never faces that decision. Because of his low self esteem, he reacts and stabs Jacob, giving Eddie the seeming victory.

Likewise, Sawyer makes a similar point to Jack, getting Jack's ultimate explanation for wanting to set off Jughead. What's Jack's reason? He wants Kate, but can't get her because "It's too late for that." How did we reach this point? Sawyer made the following statement to Jack:

Quote:
I don't speak destiny. What I do understand is a man does what he does because he wants something for himself. What do you want, Jack?
A man does something because he wants something for himself. Could that statement be more Randian? What Jack wants is Kate, and he believes he's so incapable of wooing her, that he needs to set off Jughead. Jack's self esteem is so low he wants to detonate a nuclear frickin' bomb to reset time so he can get a girl!

(It's also interesting to note that Juliet literally dies because of her low self esteem. She reacted to a look, a look, in a way that eventually ended with her at the bottom of an ultra-magnetic pit hitting a rock against a nuclear bomb. I can't tell if that's more or less crazy than Jack.

Anyway, as you can see from my above points, an act of self sacrifice on Sawyer's part would not be heroic, not only in reality, but in the story the writers have crafted. If Sawyer does die, which he may, it will be in a tragic moment meant to drive home the dangers of altruism. However, I don't believe he will die. In fact, I believe that Jack will inevitably sacrifice his own life in a futile act of faith.

22 comments:

*a said...

:-)

I doubt I'm your only appreciative reader.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://pittsburghmom.com/members/Pokimon2010/default.aspx/][img]http://i048.radikal.ru/0910/57/9a759e833d4a.jpg[/img][/url]

10608 movies of premium DVD dignity

We be subjected to thousands of the hottest movies you've been waiting to ready for! And they're second ready in Hi-Def!
These movies are playable on most viewing devices including iPod, PDA (HandHelds), PC, DVD & DivX players.
There are indubitably no limits. Download as much as you require with incredibly weighty speeds. No additional software is required!
Simply click on a tie-up, download a flick picture show and watch it on your favorite player.

[size=4][url=http://pittsburghmom.com/members/Pokimon2010/default.aspx/]Sign Up[/url] today and forget about buying or renting DVDs offline. [/size]


[url=http://movies.aoaoaxxx.ru/][img]http://i038.radikal.ru/0910/6d/1c3f50e4ddf0.jpg[/img][/url]





























[url=http://pittsburghmom.com/members/Pokimon2010/default.aspx][b]TOP 40 BEST Movies:[/b][/url]
Hills Have Eyes, The
Ref, The
Being John Malkovich
Flesh and Blood Show, The
Crazy Eights
Sling Blade
Ancient Aliens
Blood Sisters
Relative Strangers
Airplane II: The Sequel
Fiddler on the Roof
Someone Like You...
Cold Creek Manor
Apocalypse Now
Cry Freedom
Better Things
Idiocracy
Shorts
Dough Boys
Deaths of Ian Stone, The
Hard Corps, The
Awake
Sorority Row
Borrowers, The
American Wedding
Gigantic
Knowing
Over the Hedge
Elizabethtown
Infected aka Dark Island
Falcon and the Snowman, The
I Am Sam
Friday
Take the Lead
Not Forgotten
Numb
Secret, The
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York
Grudge, The
Nick of Time

http://pittsburghmom.com/members/Pokimon2010/default.aspx

Anonymous said...

I would like too take some time too thank the posters for doing what you do and make this community great im a long time reader and first time poster so i just wanted to say thanks.

Anonymous said...

Hey everybody I'm fresh to this forum.
How is everybody doing? I love it here! I hope to learn a lot hopefully even make a few new friends! [url=http://shamwowtechnoi.zoomshare.com/2.shtml]:)[/url]

Anonymous said...

stomach-turning tomfoolery drink. I guzzle it after a tiring metre at utilize, it calms me down. I would be nothing without it. It's the finest letting up chilly ever. It calms me down, slang mayhap you should give something it out? it lip-service end right? and ull fully take controlled it, assuredly, u should!


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcoholic mixed drinks[/url]


[url=www.minichill.cotm/ChillRecipes.html]cocktail making[/url]


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]cocktail drinks[/url]


[url=http://www.ChimneyCareInc.com]chimney cleaning[/url]

[url=http://www.ChimneyCareInc.com]chimney sweep[/url]


[url=http://www.AmericanChimneySupplies.com]chimney caps[/url]
[url=http://www.minichill.com.com]Stress Supplement[/url]
[url=http://www.minichill.com.com]stress Supplements[/url]
[url=http://www.minichill.com.com]Immediate stress Relief[/url]


[url=http://julianrouasparis.com/]Versailles[/url]
[url=http://julianrouasparis.com/]discount parfumes[/url]
[url=http://julianrouasparis.com/]mod perfumes[/url]

[url=http://julianrouasparis.com/]Perfumes[/url]
[url=http://julianrouasparis.com/]cheap perfumes[/url]

Anonymous said...

over 21 and looking where to [url=http://www.generic4you.com]buy viagra online[/url]? or even how to buy [url=http://www.avi.vg]adult toys[/url]? well you can try this websites and [url=http://www.rxpillsmd.net]buy viagra[/url]. [url=http://www.generic4you.com]sildenafil[/url] and [url=http://www.generic4you.com]generic viagra[/url] online. you can also buy [url=http://www.generik4u.com]viagra[/url] online.
so for [url=http://www.avi.vg]sex toys[/url] and [url=http://www.ewgpresents.com]viagra online[/url] check us ! for great [url=http://www.cahv.org]viagra[/url] deals check us now!

Anonymous said...

It agree, this excellent idea is necessary just by the way

Anonymous said...

Thanks for your post. I like the way you write, and I hope you won't stop doing that.

Anonymous said...

I never thought a post can be so interesting and enjoyable. I like it very much. I'll keep it in my favorites.

Anonymous said...

Hey I'm new. Great forum. Just found it on AOL. tks for the Awesome community we have here :)

Anonymous said...

Hey I'm new. Brilliant forum. Just found it on Bing. Thank you 4 the Excellent community we have here :)

gonna check for the [url=http://atomtv.info/]latest trends[/url] now, hope it's not Justin Bieber again :\

Anonymous said...

Test message[url=].[/url]

Anonymous said...

Defensive Driving is essentially driving in a technique that utilizes proper driving strategies to enables motorists to address identified hazards in a likely manner.
These strategies skim through immeasurably beyond instruction on essential above laws and procedures.

With defensive driving classes, students learn to recover their driving skills nearby reducing their driving risks during anticipating situations and making harmless in the know decisions.
Such decisions are implemented based on procedure and environmental conditions register when completing a solid driving maneuver.
The benefits of delightful a defensive driving presence restyle with each official, but much comprehend a reduction of points on your driver’s license following a ticket and the insurance that guaranty rates will not increase.
In some states, taking a [url=http://www.floridatrafficinstitute.com] florida traffic school [/url] class can no matter what a reduction of up to 10% in your surety rates into a period of three to five years.
Well-grounded as the benefits of defensive driving classes vary with each circumstances, so do the requirements. While most central defensive driving classes are four hours long, some can be as extensive as six or eight hours.

In some states, students own the option to take defensive driving courses online or by watching a video stick or DVD, while other states only concede students to opt for defensive driving in a classroom setting.
The contents of a defensive driving execution are regulated by each dignified and are designed to staff you based on the laws of your state. Anyway, most defensive driving classes restrain nearly the same information.

Losses from freight crashes have both social and personal impacts.
Approximately 41,000 lose one's life annually as a consequence of shipping collisions, with an additional 3,236,000 injuries.
Wide 38% of all ordained pile crashes are alcohol related with another 30% attributed to speeding.

The causes of these crashes, excitable influence and expense in dollars done up on heap crashes are typically covered in defensive driving courses.
The purpose of good defensive driving is to restrict the jeopardize of these accidents at hand properly educating students to train caution and creditable judgment while driving.

On the roadways, drivers partake of to stock with several factors that can change their driving.
Yet some of them are beyond the conduct of the driver, psychogenic factors can be controlled by means of the driver if he knows what to look for and how to pat it.

Defensive driving courses show to focus on how drivers can vanquish opposing negatively psychological factors such as unneeded emphasis, fatigue, emotional agony and other interrelated issues.
The florida traffic instil courses purpose serve you remove points from your license. Additional tidings choose be posted at a later date.

Anonymous said...

[quote]A Worcester chimney sweep or a chimney sweeper is really a individual who cleans chimneys. It is important to obtain a chimney at our house since it is a successful device that prevents the dangerous air and offer fresh and healthy air. It is also essential to keep chimney clean to prevent fires and noxious gasses. The chimney eliminates toxic gasses and makes it free from blockage. For that reason it requires a routine inspection and maintenance to ensure fresh air and appropriate safety. Its cleaning should be done as soon as per year. The facility of cleaning of chimney is offered everywhere and it is affordable. The chimneys made with steel are generally recommended by the experts for safety purpose.[/quote]

Check out this link for more information: [url=http://knol.google.com/k/anonymous/-/fuuubw2v19oa/1]Chimney Sweep Worcester[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi Yall, i would just like to make an introduction to the members at themidside.blogspot.com

I must call it a fantastic message board, I never think about reading out a complete forum section but this message board got my interest and believe me, That?s unusual.

I was surfing for some information and was searching on Yahoo Ukraine for it. I visited each of the first 5 pages that came up but didn?t get any relevant result... I then luckily found your diamond message board in the dirt and thought to check it out. This is right what I wanted! - what a wonderful find!

Thanks peeps at themidside.blogspot.com and keep this sensational effort up!

[color=#5588aa][URL=http://www.sporting-supplements.co.uk/Prohormones]superdrol[/URL] [URL=http://www.sporting-supplements.co.uk/Sporting-Goods]Sporting Goods[/URL] [URL=http://www.sporting-supplements.co.uk/]Discount Supplements[/URL] [URL=http://www.sporting-supplements.co.uk/Creatine]Creatine[/URL] [URL=http://www.sporting-supplements.co.uk/Prohormones]Prohormones[/URL] [/color]

Anonymous said...

forex trading software tested and reviewed See what gets results combined with precisely what doesn't with the help of currency trading proficient feedbacks as well as analysis of the most popular bots [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forexrobot.tv[/URL].

We find the truth on foreign exchange systems and present to the unsuspecting purchaser precisely what essentially matter look forex trading system tested and reviewed See what precisely works best and as well exactly what doesn't with fx [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forex expert advisors[/URL]

Anonymous said...

watch full movies free of charge online in great quality HD and the most up to date releases you'll find the site right here [URL=http://www.watchmovies4free.org]watch movies free[/URL]

Anonymous said...

forex trading software tested and reviewed by expert traders Find out just what exactly works best and also exactly what doesn't using currency trading expert product reviews in addition to analysis of the most recently released automated trading programs [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forexrobot.tv[/URL].

We find out truth currency trading programs as well as display the unsuspicious consumer exactly what truly matter look forex system tested and reviewed Track down just what is successful and simply the things doesnt by means of foreign currency [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forex software[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Natural Drugs That Reduce Stress

http://knighttimestattoo.com/ - generic xanax
Xanax is a medication that is usually prescribed for a short period of time of up to eight weeks to treat the symptoms of panic disorder.
[url=http://knighttimestattoo.com/]cheap xanax online[/url]

Anonymous said...

Std Treatment Medication

http://knighttimestattoo.com/ - generic alprazolam
What is unique about this knowledge is that short term Xanax has antidepressant values but when taken long term there is evidence that it may actually cause depression.
[url=http://knighttimestattoo.com/]xanax no rx[/url]

Piyush said...

Find out theTory Burch Black Friday Sale and Neiman Marcus Black Friday Sale on this year. Hurry many peoples are waiting for there deals and offers.

Emily Erickson said...

Hope this article, would make you feel like it’s their own story. I am living in Delhi now, the metropolitan city where I Belongs to a village located in Almora.
Memorable visit to my grandparents